Emma Stone Mackinnon, University of Cambridge
In the first chapter of his final work, Les damnés de la terre or The Wretched of the Earth, Frantz Fanon writes “le monde colonial est un monde compartimenté” – “the colonial world is a compartmentalized world.”[1] This sentence, repeated with slight variation in the paragraphs that follow, can appear as simple description. Yet as with so much of Fanon’s writing, his claim is at once diagnostic and a guide for action. It offers a way of understanding colonialism itself, as a matter of geography, ideas, and material practice, that works to divide up the world, to separate it into different spheres. Throughout, Fanon’s work is engaged with questions of materialism, both in the Marxist sense of historical materialism and in the more immediate and literal sense, in his attention to everyday material practices. Fanon’s description points to something powerful, and seemingly profoundly intractable – and yet therefore something anticolonialism must apprehend, and work through, in order to ultimately overcome.
Fanon’s explicit emphasis on geography and location, on a world divided up into compartments, already hints at the significance of how we locate him, and his work.[2] His thought is not simply portable, but engaged with the question of portability. Fanon’s writing and life was part and product of the colonial world he described, even as it also, itself, defied compartmentalization. Fanon’s own travel and movements were both a reflection of the colonial order, and ran contrary to it. His moves from Martinique to France and from France to Algeria were products initially of his decision to join the French military in World War II, and its patterns of military recruitment, and later of the French colonial system of education and medical training. His later transit, out of Algeria and ultimately through Accra, Cairo, Tunis, and beyond, were a reflection of transnational networks of anticolonial political actors, enabled in a straightforward material sense by the new availability of commercial air travel, and more generally by the new alliances and affiliations among revolutionary movements in the 1950s and early 1960s. As Adam Shatz emphasizes in his recent biography, their more specific geography was also a reflection of the internal politics of the Algerian resistance movement of which he was part, and where he was thought to be most useful – both diplomatically, and at times in distancing him from what others thought to be the center of the action.[3] Indeed, he was often far from what he himself had described as the source of revolutionary inspiration, the rural sites of revolutionary spontaneity he described in Wretched. His death in Bethesda, Maryland, and the return of his body to Algeria, facilitated by the US Central Intelligence Agency, offers a final testament to the significance attached to his body’s material location.
As much as Fanon travelled, his books and ideas travelled even farther. Wretched in particular is written as something of a handbook for the anticolonial revolutionary movements of its moment. The national revolutionary organizations to which it was addressed were deeply interconnected, and those networks provided the material infrastructure to circulate ideas and texts. That infrastructure involved publishers and newsletters, actors moving through nodal cities like Tunis, Accra, and Dar es Saleem, and regular meetings in the form of contentious, heady conferences. This rich networking itself was a self-consciously political project, directly defiant of the very compartmentalization Fanon described. Those conference spaces explicitly debated and renegotiated the nature of these alliances – non-aligned, Third Worldist, pan-African, Afro-Asian, etc. Fanon’s work should be understood as both commenting on and participating in this self-conscious negotiation over coalition building and the bases of international solidarity. His work takes his native Martinique and adopts Algeria as immediate context, while also drawing references from liberation struggles against French and British rule more widely, and raising questions about those struggles’ interconnections as well as their comparability to Black American struggles in the United States.
Fanon’s work raises further questions of compartmentalization. It is written in multiple genres and addressed to different and disparate audiences. He wrote historical analysis, political theory, activist tracts, narrative prose, and clinical notes. The very chapter organization of Wretched reflects this fragmentation. His work offers serious contributions to distinct and often separate fields. His work engages with multiple traditions and debates, and has been read retroactively into even more: Marxism and its legacies, psychology, psychoanalysis, existentialism, anticolonialism, and postcolonial thought. It intervenes in critical questions of his moment, not just with new answers but with new modes of analysis, which yield new diagnoses and prognoses in turn.
Fanon’s claim about compartmentalization and colonialism comes as part of an explicit discussion of the portability of Marxism, and of what it means to move this particular system of analysis into a different place from where it was initially conceived. Notably, his answer is not about the impossibility of portability, but instead about the importance of considering how questions appear differently in different places. This is not just because the details change, but the very structure. He writes: “Looking at the immediacies of the colonial context, it is clear that what divides this world is first and foremost what species, what race one belongs to. In the colonies the economic infrastructure is also a superstructure. The cause is effect: You are rich because you are white, you are white because you are rich. This is why a Marxist analysis should always be slightly stretched when it comes to addressing the colonial issue.”[4] The suggestion of a slight stretching of the analysis is an understatement: his claim is that, in a colonial context, the relationships of causality are different. This confounds any orthodox view of race as somehow simply epiphenomenal to material interests; it also defies, he continues, any analysis of colonialism as simply an earlier stage of capitalism. Under colonialism, ideology itself, he suggests, works differently.
In Wretched especially, Fanon engages the question of how to understand the intersection of colonialism and capitalism as a problem of race, economic development, and revolutionary strategy. The book addresses longstanding intellectual debates in Marxism, as well as questions facing a transnational audience that, in 1961, was looking to the Algerian Revolution as a touchstone for anticolonial movements elsewhere. Resisting colonialism, Fanon argues, requires thinking across multiple registers. As he expounds over the course of the book, this has implications for how one might apply Marxist class analysis, changing how one thinks about the lumpenproletariat, the native intellectual, the party leadership, and the possibility of revolutionary agency. In a sense, these are questions, channeling Marx’s closing formulation in the Communist Manifesto, about who has what to lose and what to gain.[5] For Fanon, this is not just a material question; the material is inseparable from the psychological. Colonialism works across multiple registers, and any viable analysis of colonialism must do the same. In a colonial world, systems of exploitation and of investment are both material and psychological; liberation, in turn, must also be both.
Crucially, this aspect of colonialism – what I have been glossing as the inseparability of the material and the psychological – is why, for Fanon, any orthodox division of base and superstructure is impossible in a colonial context. Race is not mere ideological superstructure, but has causal power as well. At the same time, it is not a part of the “base” – part of why he is so critical of any evidence of racial essentialism among authors associated with the Negritude movement.[6] Race is not natural, but historically produced by colonialism’s parcelling out of the world. This is where his debts to existentialism come in as well, and in particular his insistence, most explicit in Black Skin, White Masks, on theorizing race as part of “l’expérience vécue” or “lived experience” – a phrase he does not exactly coin (in either the French or the English), but the contemporary popularity of which is in part indebted to him.
Fanon’s understanding of race and its implications for his politics is itself among the more divisive issues in his contemporary reception, and raises questions itself about how we might read different parts of his work together. Is there a divide between the parts of his work that are at times branded as pessimist, and those that are more insistent, even prophetic, about the possibility not just of change but of radically new beginnings? Is there a divide between the Fanon of Black Skin, White Masks and the Fanon of Wretched of the Earth – written so far apart, temporally and geographically? Is, say, the man narrating through his own tears at the end of the famous fifth chapter of Black Skin the same as the author invoking the need to “set afoot a new man” and begin a new history of humanity in the conclusion of Wretched? Reading these together requires we reconcile a certain pessimism about one’s current condition with a determined hopefulness for change. After all, Fanon’s hope for the future isn’t without its attention the ‘pitfalls’ and difficulties of overcoming the legacies of past injustice. Wretched is as much concerned with the process of achieving true independence, or true decolonization, after the end of foreign rule as it is with the initial process of revolutionary rupture – and both are presented as profoundly difficult. His assessment of the present, and the prospects for change, are clear-eyed, but also doggedly determined. He does not suggest that victory is inevitable, or even likely. Instead, the difficulty of achieving change, it’s very improbability, is part of what makes it so urgent.
Fanon’s politics begin not from an ideal vision of justice, but from a clear sense of the crises of the present, their deep historical causes, and the pitfalls in any path forward. The demand for a new history is a demand based on necessity more than on anything we might call optimism. This is where his particular combination of diagnostics and dialectics has the most analytic pay off. Wretched’s enumeration of the stages through which certain groups must pass is not a tragic pronouncement of a necessary fate, but a diagnosis that describes the mechanisms of change – not as linear or intentional, or even strictly stadial, but as a process of repeated transformation. His treatment of violence, I would argue, is not strictly redemptive or laudatory, but diagnostic, treating it both as symptom and as, at least potentially, part of a process of change, capable of transforming material as well as psychic conditions.
The essays in this collection speak to the persistence of the problems he diagnosed, as well as the usefulness of the diagnoses. They suggest his analysis is portable, but also requires some stretching; that the forces that parcel out the world are not binary, but multifaceted and dynamic. Some of the essays speak, as well, to the way he himself may have been vulnerable to the forces of fragmentation that he depicted. If Fanon is currently in vogue, it is perhaps neither for his optimism nor his pessimism, but for the diagnostic power of his work, and the importance, as a matter of both politics and psychology, of properly apprehending one’s situation for any process of working through. Fanon was attentive to the persistence of the problems he described: the reach of colonialism into different places and realms, the power of material and psychic investments, the multiple ways in which the future can be overdetermined. He was attentive to how those seeking change may reproduce the very patterns they seek to alter, to the challenges they would face, to how apparent change might just be one stage in a broader process. And he was insistent about the urgency of continuing to try anyway.
[1] Frantz Fanon, Les damnés de la terre (Paris: Éditions La Découverte & Syros, 2002), 41. Originally published by Librairie François Maspero in 1961. English translation quoted from Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, trans. Richard Philcox, (New York: Grove Press, 2007), 28. Alternately translated by Constance Farringdon as “The colonial world is a world divided into compartments,” in Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, trans. Constance Farringdon (London: Penguin Classics, 2001), 29.
[2] On the importance of reading Fanon in context, see Muriam Haleh Davis, “The US Academy and the Provincialization of Fanon,” Los Angeles Review of Books, November 9, 2002, https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/the-us-academy-and-the-provincialization-of-fanon/
[3] Adam Shatz, The Rebel’s Clinic (London: Apollo, 2024).
[4] Philcox translation, 29. In the original : “Quand on aperçoit dans son immédiateté le contexte colonial, il est patent que ce qui morcelle le monde c’est d’abord le fait d’appartenir ou non à telle espèce, à telle race. Aux colonies, l’infrastructure économique est également une superstructure. La cause est conséquence: on est riche parce que blanc, on est blanc parce que riche. C’est pourquoi les analyses marxistes doivent être toujours légèrement distendues chaque fois qu’on aborde le problème colonial” (Fanon, Les damnés de la terre, 43). Alternately translated by Farringdon as: “When you examine at close quarters the colonial context, it is evident that what parcels out the world is to begin with the fact of belonging to or not belonging to a given race, a given species. In the colonies the economic substructure is also a superstructure. The cause is the consequence; you are rich because you are white, you are white because you are rich. This is why the Marxist analysis should always be slightly stretched every time we have to do with the colonial problem” (30-31).
[5] See, for example, Fanon, Les damnés de la terre, 108.
[6] Fanon’s most explicit engagement with Negritude is contained in Chapters 1 and 5 of Black Skin, White Masks, and in the chapter “On National Culture” of The Wretched of the Earth.
