Specters of Revolutions: Fanonian Reflections on Toward the African/Arab Revolution

Hanene Baroumi, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences of Tunis

In Toward the African Revolution, Frantz Fanon poses a peculiar but thought-provoking question: “[w]ho are they, in truth, those creatures, who hide, who are hidden by social truth beneath the attributes of bicot, bounioule, arabe, raton, sidi, mon z’ami?”[1] Fanon’s question on the nature of dissidents and revolutionaries brings one to consider the nature of revolution itself. One can argue that revolutions are never obsolete. Indeed, revolutions are always “spectered” as they seem to haunt human history. The word haunting unveils questions on legacy, history and memory. Fanon’s writings on revolutions spark an engagement with other texts, times and possibilities of resistance. Literary works and political discourses on Arab revolutions, for instance, seem to share similar questions on the nature of revolutions and revolutionaries. Fanon’s reflection and provocative analysis of revolutions in Africa urge readers to think about the aftermaths of the Arab Spring. The post Arab spring literary representations of dissidence and revolution seem to unveil and challenge certainties about language, gender roles, elite culture along with the holy myth of a finished revolution. Arab writers, like Fanon, grapple with questions of nationalism, the essence of revolution and the role of revolutionaries, violence, and the socio-political realities of their societies as they seek to understand and reflect on the revolutionary struggles unfolding in the Arab world.

Revolutions in Fanon’s writings are “in the making”; they reveal the multiple jeopardy that Africans face as they attempt to reclaim their voices and identities. Accordingly, revolutions are constructed and deconstructed in experiences and narratives about the self and the other; they become sites for negotiating other possibilities of becoming African, Arab, and militant. Like Fanon’s inquiries into the nature of revolutions, Arab writers appear to engage in parallel explorations as they examine the complexities of identity, the struggles for liberation, and the socio-political landscapes that shape their narratives. Through their works, they explore the historical and contemporary forces that shape their societies, seeking to articulate the aspirations and challenges faced by their communities in the pursuit of justice and self-determination.

This paper seeks to examine the diverse manifestations and metaphors of revolution in the writings of Fanon and some Arab writers. The study of their poetics of re-writing and re-inventing other possibilities of becoming revolutionary reflects on some possible alliances between the past and the present in the MENA region as they foster a direct relationship with political and cultural transformations. This paper argues that a Fanonian dream of “This Africa to Come” and rethinking revolutions through the African and Arab context can offer new interpretations of becoming revolutionary. It reads two critical texts about the Arab Spring through the lens of Fanonian readings of revolution: Egyptian novelist Alaa Al Aswani’s The Republic of False Truths and Tunisian writer Kamel Riahi’s Frankenstein Tunis. These texts interrogate the aftermath of Egyptian and Tunisian “revolutions” in order to reveal the socio-political effects on people as they might become the new “wretched of the earth.”

On Revolutions and Other Apost Dreams

It so happens that the unpreparedness of the educated classes, the lack of practical links between them and the mass of the people, their laziness, and, let it be said, their cowardice at the decisive moment of the struggle will give rise to tragic mishaps. National consciousness, instead of being the all-embracing crystallization of the innermost hopes of the whole people, instead of being the immediate and most obvious result of the mobilization of the people, will be in any case only an empty shell, a crude and fragile travesty of what it might have been.

—Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth (148)

Frantz Fanon warns the reader against dreaming dangerously[2] about revolutions.  Revolutions, he prophesies, may betray the wretched who made them. A revolution might become an “empty shell, a crude and fragile travesty” at the hands of the unprepared. And what could be more important today than speaking about “tragic mishaps” and the “crystallization of the innermost hopes” —of revolutions and revolutionaries?

At the heart of Fanon’s thinking on revolution in Africa and elsewhere, as we infer from his words in The Wretched of the Earth, is a venture into reading moments of “national consciousness” otherwise. Fanon’s Black Skin, White Masks, The Wretched of the Earth, Toward the African Revolution each in their own way reveal the intersection between colonial experiences and national struggles. Fanon maps out the past by rethinking historical injustices as they offer a leap into the present, already loaded with historical traumas, projecting into the future of the wretched.

To speak of memory as knowledge of both present and future carries with it the special significance of Fanon’s writing about other possibilities of being African and becoming revolutionary. Fanon’s “wretched of the earth,” demarcated as the miserable and pitiable sufferers, are not only at the margin of history and memory but are also at the margin of revolutions. The word wretched reveals the failure of revolutions as they do not achieve their goals. Writing about the miserable African – and, dare one say it, Arab –attempts to reclaim voices often silenced in the grand narratives of war, speeches of independence and freedom, and official news discourses to wrestle them into history and memory.

Fanon’s work reveals his examination of history and memory, which are forces of cultural, economic, and political change, to say the least. In effect, one can look more closely at his dissident writing and voice as he confronts historical injustices and false narratives. Fanon’s reading of history is loaded with encounters with the trauma of pre-colonial and post-colonial tragedies. The traumas of yesterday’s colonial wretchedness, as this paper suggests, are the traumas of today’s revolutionaries and the revolution itself.

It is from this perspective that this article asks: What is a revolution for Fanon? What does it mean for a revolution to be a travesty? Do revolutions breed new species or monsters? Do they make the wretched more wretched? And how do post-Arab Spring narratives seem to highlight similar questions about revolutions?

 The Prophet speaks: On Dreams and Realities

“Each generation must out of relative obscurity discover its mission, fulfill it, or betray it.”

—Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth (206)

Fanon observes that genuine revolutions must be creative; otherwise, they die and take away revolutionaries. Revolutions, accordingly, must unite people to understand the truth, here referring to a new state of mind. It signals people’s transition from ignorance to knowledge and their ongoing struggle to change political, cultural, and socio-economic realities that impede change and hold people back. He posits that African people “come to know themselves. They have decided, in the name of the whole continent, to weigh in strongly against the colonial regime” (The Wretched, 164). Self-knowledge, or what is referred to as discovering one’s mission, can generate moments of truth and change. Fanon posits that to think (of) revolution, one must think truth. What is more, revolution is defined as a journey towards self-liberation. Fanon links revolution to responsibility, but it is the responsibility of the nationalists, the elite, and the political parties:

The national government, if it wants to be national, ought to govern by the people and for the people, for the outcasts and by the outcasts. No leader, however valuable he may be, can substitute himself for the popular will; and the national government, before concerning itself about international prestige, ought first to give back their dignity to all citizens, fill their minds and feast their eyes with human things, and create a prospect that is human because conscious and sovereign men dwell therein.[3]

Fanon’s words reflect his philosophy of revolution as a people’s experience manifested in their articulation of liberation. The “national” consciousness argument is best illustrated in the marriage between theory and praxis. In advancing this thesis, Fanon seeks to suggest that a revolution—while it should be praised for its attempt to give dignity to all citizens—has to be called into question when it comes to examining political and social realities produced by national governments. Such political and social change in no way stops at the level of theorizing emancipation and social justice, but must unite people and leaders in action. Fanon warns against conflating people’s longing for socio-economic changes with the falsified discourses of the pernicious national bourgeoisie. Fanon remains skeptical of new governments that could falsify facts and seize power to create a new form of domination. He then adds:

Now the nationalist bourgeoisies, who in region after region hasten to make their own fortunes and to set up a national system of exploitation, do their utmost to put obstacles in the path of this “Utopia.” The national bourgeoisies, who are quite clear as to what their objectives are, have decided to bar the way to that unity, to that coordinated effort on the part of two hundred and fifty million men to triumph over stupidity, hunger, and inhumanity at one and the same time. This is why we must understand that African unity can only be achieved through the upward thrust of the people, and under the leadership of the people, that is to say, in defiance of the interests of the bourgeoisie.[4]

Fanon’s warnings about betrayal, exploitation, and failure highlight the defective link between people’s demands and the agendas of the nationalist bourgeoisie. Fanon holds that revolution is often betrayed by “new species of men” who carry the seeds of more destruction and corruption. In other words, the new leaders become the new enemies to resist and rebel against. In Fanon’s view, the encounters with failure and hostility should not result in antagonism and conflict. What he suggests instead is an original mode of thinking about revolution, through dissident voices:

The clear, unreal, idyllic light of the beginning is followed by a semi-darkness that bewilders the senses. The people find out that the iniquitous fact of exploitation can wear a black face, or an Arab one; and they raise the cry of “Treason!” But the cry is mistaken; and the mistake must be corrected. The treason is not national, it is social. The people must be taught to cry “Stop thief!”[5]

From this perspective, revolutionaries have to adapt themselves to the new struggle for liberation. Breaking the chains of illusion and disillusionment is necessary if people want to be treated as human beings. The people, Fanon reveals, rebel when they are deprived of truth; if they know truth, they can know themselves, which can change their experiences of the world. Fanon argues, “To tell the truth, the proof of success lies in a whole social structure being changed from the bottom up.”[6]

A similar bottom-up reading of revolutions and their histories can elucidate details about national and social articulations of pain, hope, memory, illusion, trauma, and dangerous dreams. Here we arrive at the crux of Fanon’s philosophy of social change, or revolution. Fanon is aware that ‘History’ profanes revolutions because revolution is sacred like truth. In other words, he is aware that only the ‘brave’ can be revolutionary, and only the truth is revolutionary, and truth always falls outside history. Truth could only rise from the ashes of others’ memories and histories.[7] To explore the themes of revolution, freedom, and dreams and hopes of revolt in the works of Alaa Al Aswani and Kamel Riahi, one can delve into how these texts resonate with Fanon’s writing of revolution. Both writers reflect on the complexities and dangers of revolutionary movements, revealing the perils of uprising both in the past and present. Fanon’s philosophy of revolution echo throughout their text, highlighting the ongoing struggles of African people in their quest for dignity and justice.

The Rebel Speaks: Trust the Tale not the Teller[8]

“O my body, make of me always a man who questions!”

—Frantz Fanon, Black Skin, White Masks, (232)

Adopting Fanon’s logic can help understand other moments of failed uprisings. Alaa Al Aswani’s The Republic of False Truths (2018) and Tunisian writer Kamel Riahi’s Frankenstein Tunis (2023) are narratives of thwarted dreams and lost hopes. Their texts invoke the voices of rebels and monsters torn between revolutionary dreams and dark realities, hope and despair, and order and disorder. Just as Fanon spoke about “fulfilling” or “betraying” the post-colonial revolutions, Al Aswani and Riahi share similar experiences of narrating stories of betrayal and lost moments of change in the aftermath of Arab uprisings. The texts become dissident representations of historical conditions and people’s attitudes toward these conditions. The Republic of False Truths and Frankenstein Tunis show, transmit, perform, deconstruct, construct, and unfold counter-narratives about failed uprisings in Egypt and Tunisia. Both books were banned by authorities under the pretext of ‘slandering the state,’ transgressing boundaries, and destabilizing order. Al Aswani and Riahi audaciously challenge the official narratives about fulfilled or finished revolutions. They are outspoken activists and intellectuals who seek to speak truth to power. The messages in the texts are clear, and the encounter with the post-spring realities is vivid.

The Republic of False Truths, جمهورية كأن, unveils the political and social hypocrisy of a country falling apart. Everything seems “كأن,” “as if” it is fine, ordered, and fulfilled. This Arabic word “كأن,” chosen by Al Aswani, underlines the political manipulation of news and minds where everything looks fine, ordered, and fulfilled. Egyptians after the revolution seem to be consumed by debates about national identity and social and economic changes. Contrary to the rosy picture propagated by the political regime, revolutionaries seem to suffer alone in silence. “False truths” are just exposed through the polyphonic stories of different characters who resisted or participated in the Tahrir Square events in 2011.  Policemen, religious figures, workers, schoolteachers, trade union activists, government officials, young men and women, actors, and factory owners are depicted as they share their narratives of protest or domination.

Al Aswani’s text gives voice to the alternative experiences of sons and fathers, daughters and mothers, government officials and rebels, teachers and actors as they share their thoughts of revolution and uprising. Al Aswani addresses the reader directly about how to interpret and think about The Republic of False Truths: 

Dear Reader,

You will never know who I am because I shall sign this book with a pseudonym. I am not afraid. I come, thank God, from a family of brave men, generation upon generation. The only thing is that we live in a lying, backward society that adores delusions, and I am not willing to pay the price of others’ stupidity. I have lived for fifty-five years, and most of those years I have spent in deep thought, which has led me to comprehend a number of truths, which it is now my duty to both proclaim and document. The theories that I shall put forward in this book would merit academic study, were we living in a decent society. We are, however, in Egypt, where the serious thinker and the brilliant scientist find no recognition, and where glory – and what glory! – goes to liars and impostors. Let me start my theory with the following question: ‘What is the essence of the relationship that ties a man to a woman in Egypt?

Al Aswani’s loaded question about the relationship between a man and a woman in Egypt is an alibi. One might rephrase the question as follows: what is the essence of the relationship that ties a revolutionary to a nation or to a revolution that is faltering? The sarcastic representation of love, revolution, and relationships that follows in the narrative reveals the author’s fury. Al Aswani’s characters fail to answer this question as they are surrounded by ‘bitchy mothers’ and ‘ruthless fathers’ who fail to love each other. Love and revolution can blind people to the realities of Egypt. Everything seems to be false. The republic is false too. Only the revolution is true, the writer says:

It’s the truth, Mazen. I really am ‘nothing’ and all the young people who took part in the revolution are ‘nothing’. They did to us, and will go on doing to us, whatever they want. They will kill us and abuse us sexually and put out our eyes with shotgun pellets and no one will bring them to trial and no one will hold them to account. Do you know why? Because we’re ‘nothing’. Because we mounted a revolution that nobody needed and nobody wanted. I know you still believe in the People. I, though, will never believe in them. This people, whose freedom and dignity the best among us gave their lives to defend, doesn’t want freedom and dignity. You used to ask, ‘Why the hatred that we see on the faces of the officers as they kill us?’ Because they hate what we represent. Because we’re demanding to be citizens, not slaves. The people for whose sake we rose up, Mazen, hate us and hate the revolution […] Everything in Egypt is a lie, except for the revolution. Only the revolution is true, which is why they hate it, because it shows up their corruption and their hypocrisy. Egypt is the Republic of False Truths, and we presented the Egyptians with the reality and they hated it from the depths of their hearts.

The above passage deserves to be cited in full as it echoes Fanon’s arguments about tragic ends, alienated revolutionaries, and thwarted hopes. Changes in state power, accordingly, fail to bring about social transformation and correspond with revolutionaries’ aspirations. The voice of Asma Zanaty, a dissident revolutionary and school teacher, seems to represent the many voices of those betrayed by people’s silence and submission to corruption, injustice, and exploitation. Al Aswani’s affirmative defiance is illustrated in his refusal to yield to the political manipulation of revolution. Al Aswani’s statement “only the revolution is true” in the Republic of False Truths is a locus where two antagonistic movements are at work: the revolutionaries and the nonrevolutionaries. The clash between truths and lies played out at the political manipulation of revolution, transforms people’s minds about power and resistance.

By the same token, Fanon warns against those who seem to be manipulated by a new state power. In Black Skin, White Masks, he observes that:

Sometimes people hold a core belief that is very strong. When they are presented with evidence that works against that belief, the new evidence cannot be accepted. It would create a feeling that is extremely uncomfortable, called cognitive dissonance. And because it is important to protect the core belief, they will rationalize, ignore and even deny anything that doesn’t fit in with the core belief.[9]

Indeed, social and political changes require a new understanding because revolutions create new realities and articulations. Fanon seems to have some sympathy for people who cannot fathom a different reality. People have to step out of their comfort zones and face truths about themselves, their failure and their ignorance, to ‘spring into’ the possibilities of being a citizen, a free Man, and an independent human being. The transition is often painful as it entails breaking deep-rooted chains of ignorance and developing new cognitive skills. That is why Fanon adds: “uprooted, pursued, baffled, doomed to watch the dissolution of the truths that he has worked out for himself one after another, he has to give up projecting onto the world an antinomy that coexists with him.”[10] Egyptians, who belong to the wretched of the earth, feel uprooted and baffled as they fail to understand the truth.

On Monsters: To Speak or Not to Speak

“Decolonization is quite simply the replacing of a certain “species” of men by another “species” of men.”

—Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth (35)

“Zombies, believe me, are more terrifying than colonists.”

― Frantz Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth (56)

In his analysis of revolutionary times, Fanon uses the metaphors of “monsters,” “zombies,” and “serpent-men,” to describe the birth of new species who are often the official spokespersons of revolutions. The metaphors depict leaders who betray the people and put an end to the revolution. The monstrous imagery stands for the embodiment of the dehumanization of the revolution’s enemies. The metaphors evoke the evil that they can inflict — an evil beyond human knowledge. Fanon says:

There are maleficent spirits which intervene every time a step is taken in the wrong direction, leopard-men, serpent-men, six-legged dogs, zombies—a whole series of tiny animals or giants which create around the native a world of prohibitions, of barriers and of inhibitions far more terrifying than the world of the settler.[11]

Like Fanon on monsters and their frightening world, Tunisian writer Kamel Riahi describes similar monsters in Frankenstein Tunis. The text includes articles and literary allusions that reflect on post-revolutionary Tunisia mainly through the metaphor of Frankenstein. Frankenstein is both the president, Kais Saied, and the people who grapple with the father or leader absence. Tunisians are described as orphans and uprooted children who dream about returning home. In his article, “A Night in Tunisia,” Riahi shares his own experience of the Tunisian Uprising:

When Tunisians see that some members of the old regime have been named to cabinet posts, there is a new wave of disturbances, and people start saying that revolution has been stolen from them […] I support the revolution and, like so many young people, worry that it will be stolen from us by the traitors, thieves and killers who have ruled us for far too long. (227)

Like Fanon and Al Aswani, Riahi trusts revolutions but doubts the new ruler’s resistance to truth and change. More to say, he doubts the people who are described as slaves because of their fear and oppression. Riahi argues that Arab peoples are enslaved by their terror of freedom and truth (238).  Riahi criticizes Saied’s constitutional coup, arguing that the suspension of Tunisian parliament serves to stifle the very revolution he claims to support. The text forewarns of different attempts to intimidate people who defend the freedom of expression, as evidenced by the imprisonment of activists and journalists who advocate for freedom and political opposition.

By the same token, Fanon holds that people grapple with the meaning of change and the post-revolution reality: “[t]he people, the people who had given everything in the difficult moments of the struggle for national liberation wonder, with their empty hands and bellies, as to the reality of their victory.”[12] Fanon, here, seems to capture the tragedy of the revolution: people’s ignorance breeds fear and makes them yield themselves to the new power. People do not know how to respond to change. The new reality frightens them. They wait for a savior to tell them what to do next. People are afraid of the new reality because they are hungry and ignorant. Hopes about social transformation, justice, and dignity are turned into bitter disappointment. The new leaders, transformed into terrifying monsters and zombies, seize power from the people.

Riahi adds that Arabs, too, create their own Frankenstein. What is interesting for the reader to think about is the analogy made between Mary Shelley’s monster and the Tunisian monster. Both Victor Frankenstein and the Tunisian people longed for the mother’s presence as they were traumatized by pain, anxiety, and wretchedness. The monster, accordingly, could denote aid — the dream of a possible “man of or from the people.”[13] However, monsters cannot overcome their monstrosity, and there is worse to come: monsters, too, can betray people. Riahi highlights the analogy between Victor’s dream and people’s hope, between the people and the state, and between knowledge and ignorance. He states that Victor’s monster is an imaginary and fictive product of scientific experimentation, whereas the Tunisian or Arab monster is the material product and the living emblem of human choices, the product of people’s ignorance and fear (244).  The monster seems to bring more destruction and pain.

Riahi’s bleak world of a betrayed revolution and a country falling apart uses bitter language, which points to similar experiences examined in Fanon’s and Al Aswani’s writings about revolutions and monsters. Fanon, Al Aswani, and Riahi were unapologetic, daring, and dissident. Their texts speak truths and facts. The present article examines Fanon’s reflections on revolution, resistance, and political change. Reading Al Aswani’s and Riahi’s texts through the lens of Fanon, or, to put it differently, seeing Fanon’s legacy through the lens of Arab texts on revolutions and uprisings, allows the reader to understand more about the present movements of uprising in the world. It is intriguing to compare how different texts, from past and present, speak to each other in provocative and creative ways. They become a gateway, opening up a different mode of thinking about revolutions. ‘The Prophet, the Rebel, and the Monster’ dream dangerously about a new text and a new world: that of the unwretched. What Fanon taught us yesterday and today is that “when we revolt it’s not for a particular culture. We revolt simply because, for many reasons, we can no longer breathe.”[14]

References

Achebe, Chinua. A Man of the People. Heinemann, 1988.

Al Aswani, Alaa. The Republic of False Truths. Translated by S.R. Fellow, Faber, 2021.

Caruth, Cathy. Literature in the Ashes of History. Johns Hopkins University Press, 2013.

Frantz, Fanon. Black Skin, White Masks. Translated by Charles Lam Markmann, Pluto Press, 2008.

―. Toward the African Revolution. Translated by Haakon Chevalier, Grove Press, 1988.

―. The Wretched of the Earth. Translated by Constance Farrington, Grove Press, 1963.

Lawrence, D.H. Lady Chatterley’s Lover. Penguin Classics, 2000.

Riahi, Kamel. Frankenstein Tunis. Dar Al Kitab, 2023.

Žižek, Slavoj. The Year of Dreaming Dangerously. Verso Books, 2012.

[1] Fanon, Toward the African Revolution, 3.

[2] It is inspired by Slavoj Zizek’s The Year of Dreaming Dangerously, 2012.

[3] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 205.

[4] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 164.

[5] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 145.

[6] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 65.

[7] With a nod to Cathy Caruth’s Literature in the Ashes of History, 2013.

[8] I borrow this expression from D.H. Lawrence.

[9] Fanon, Black Skin, White Masks, 119.

[10] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 2.

[11] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 55.

[12] Fanon, Towards the African Revolution, 187.

[13] Inspired by Chinua’s Achebe Man of the People, 1988.

[14] Fanon, The Wretched of the Earth, 65.