Fanon and the Wretched of the Sea: The Forbidden Mobility of Tunisian Youth

Wael Garnaoui, University of Sousse

From my experience as a clinical psychologist working with Maghrebi and Sub-Saharan migrant populations in France, and from my doctoral and postdoctoral research with undocumented Tunisian migrants and families of missing migrants in Tunisia, a return to Frantz Fanon’s writings on colonized populations has illuminated my understanding of the attachment and identification of postcolonial subjects with the West, which I have termed the “desire for the West.”

My hypothesis is that the West maintains its domination over Southern populations through a well-studied immigration policy—a policy that is an inheritance of colonial policies that justified their domination over people through a psychiatric discourse rooted in the principles of the School of Algiers.[1] While the colonial space is primarily an economic exploitation of local labor and natural resources, that exploitation was accompanied by the production of knowledge about colonized peoples which would become essential for modern colonialism’s access to essentially “foreign” territories. Fanon criticized the practices of the School of Algiers, wherein colonial psychiatrists, convinced of the inferiority of indigenous populations, invented a classification of psychological pathologies based on a supposed psychology of the people. This colonial imaginary remains at play today in consular attitudes (visa procedures) that recall old colonial assertion such as Antoine Porot’s definition of Maghreb indigenous people was something « halfway between the primitive man and the evolved Westerner».

This essay uses an archaeology of knowledge and a psycho-historical approach with a detailed review of events marking the colonial and postcolonial periods related to the mobility of populations in Tunisia.The exploration of the link between colonization and immigration demonstrates the transfer of certain colonial practices to the management of immigrants and migration flows. The political context and colonial division strategies played a significant role in the racial classification and hierarchy of populations from either the North or South of the Mediterranean. Borders have been the primary tool for demarcation and identification of this “other.” Colonial strategies domination continues today in the management of migration.

It is worth noting that many internal expert reports within the colonial administration are underpinned by a conception of immigration that is overdetermined by the colonial conflict.  Since the independence of colonized countries, the experience of colonial administration officials transitioned into the management of colonial migrants—not only at the state level but also in the service of major corporations entrusted with selecting and administering labor. These conversions contributed significantly to the continuation of colonial structures in contemporary immigration management.[2]

A review of the works of Frantz Fanon and the postulates of the School of Algiers allows us to grasp contemporary qualifications of the “symptoms” presented by harraga (clandestine migrants) and jihadists by shedding light on the colonial discourse. I argue that the thought patterns of psychiatric discourse of the colonial period continue to shape not only the administration of labor migration but also the migrant’s psyche and their desire for the West. It is these thought patterns (or their avatars) that have produced a new administrative category, that of the “clandestine” migrant (harraga) after the creation of the European Union’s Schengen area. The link between harraga and terrorists became concrete only after the September 11th attacks and the large measures reinforcing Western borders. This essay therefore studies the immobility of Tunisian subjects through the analysis of the psychological repercussions of visa refusals on people and their psyche.

Psychanalysis of the Prevented Subject

The act of migrating is marked by a process of hindrance to the realization of a wish, an identification, or a desire. In this section, I return to the most verifiable mechanism that constructs obstacles to the desire for elsewhere and otherness—the Schengen visa mechanism. The visa system is the primary obstacle to the realization of the right to free movement of people from Southern Mediterranean countries. This system sorts “good” and “bad” immigrants based on criteria that intertwine economic, social, cultural, and biological factors. Behind a bureaucratic institution that presents itself as neutral, namely the consulate or embassy, power dynamics are at play. Depending on the economic situation of the host countries, visa offices control migration flows by imposing selection criteria. These places are where « the national identity of passengers is objectified when crossing from one territory to another and from one sovereignty to another, and where discrimination between nationals of the country and foreigners occurs ».[3]

The simple desire to travel therefore requires a complex and cold visa application procedure. A young Tunisian must meet several conditions to submit an application that might be considered, accepted, or rejected. Every candidate for travel from Tunisia to Europe is suspected of illegal immigration and must prove an attachment guaranteeing their return to their home country. Thus, the nature of the documents and travel justifications required from candidates depends on the risk of illegal immigration. The visa application classification system does not follow a general law, even though the economically weakest populations are the primary targets of refusals. Beyond economic structuring, several criteria are required in this bureaucratic and sovereign visa classification: nationality, age, marital status, occupation, place of residence, property ownership, educational level, and diplomas, among others. Even individuals with a high set of resources and privileges in the social hierarchy can have their visa application denied without any explicit reason. Every visa application process induces anxiety and doubt in most applicants. Consular offices constitute the first bureaucratic line in managing the “migration risk.” As Federica Infantino shows in her study on the Italian consulate in Morocco, it is upstream and during the visa granting process that most effective control procedures take place to block individuals before their departure.[4]

When a visa applicant receives their passport from the TLS Contact visa center,[5] they are given a document justifying the consular decision, especially in the case of a visa refusal. Most often, the reason for refusal is cited as “Your intention to leave the territory of the Member States before the visa’s expiration could not be established.” This determination by consular services that the travel candidate might prolong their stay and remain irregularly in French territory after their visa expires is based on the documents provided insufficiently demonstrating the willingness to return and an “attachment” to the home country. TLS Contact offers assistance in challenging this decision: “We can help you assemble a complete dossier justifying the purpose of your stay and contesting this reason for refusal.” A vague avenue of appeal is mentioned without the cancellation of the consular decision; it involves reconstructing a dossier and advancing new fees similar to the amounts of the rejected application.[6] This appeal can be costly; many individuals subject to migration policies speak of the “plunder and theft” of migration systems. Commerce operates within policies that appear sovereign and border-related, often profiting from situations of destitution but especially from the fantasies and hopes of people aspiring to improve their situations. If this form of “looting” is indeed evident in emigration societies due to the aspiration to migrate, undocumented migrants are not spared in the host society’s mercantile logic, which lies at the heart of migration management systems.[7]

Assessing Intentionality and the “Will” to Return.

A denied visa signifies that the applicant lacks the intention to return to their home country. Rather than maintaining a classical, administrative view based on evidence and law, the border mechanisms now aim to judge and ascertain the applicant’s intentionality. Beyond material evidence, the applicant must present guarantees of goodwill. In psychology, willpower is defined as the capacity to carry out an intentional act consciously. Voluntary action is based on the principle of controlling one’s own actions. This attitude regards visa applicants as unpredictable and insincere individuals incapable of controlling their own actions.

Considering the “will” to return means controlling that will. According to psychoanalysis, “will” is an expression of an unconscious desire; it results from an interplay of unconscious impulses and instincts. Only when a person is in harmony with their desire does the will follow. Denying a visa to applicants who meet all objective conditions means that consular authorities make a diagnosis—a form of psychological assessment of the migrant’s unconscious desire. Branding the applicant as a “potential illegal migrant” lacking goodwill amounts to an intrusion into the intention and temporality of travel based on implicit psychoanalysis carried out by administrators. This assessment is based on a random moral judgement depending on selection criteria and the judgment of visa office personnel.

To act freely, the visa applicant must be capable of consciously determining their actions and not obeying their unconscious desires. An applicant whose visa application is denied is considered to be below the full force of their psychic powers driving them to action. They suffer from a will disorder, a form of aboulia—they are simply deprived of willpower. Such a person represents a state of generalized psychic inhibition, similar to individuals affected by aboulia. Consular services, without the training or legitimacy for assessment or diagnosis, replace psychiatric institutions and implicitly announce a form of pathological classification, psychologizing the will of a travel candidate, thus rendering them immobile. Freedom of movement or mobility, in this case, is part of the “normal” capacities of the ego. What is at stake is a “functional limitation of the ego,” linked to “a mere decrease in function. The inhibited ego perceives a barrier to its sphere of action, experiencing itself as a hindered agent.”[8] According to Didier Bigo, “the granting of an individual visa is, in this regard, an exception to the exception (which is why it follows a logic of ‘rarity’ in the minds of those who issue them). It is a restoration of trust in the individual after the ordeal of suspicion cast on a whole nation.”[9]

This deprivation of will returns us to Frantz Fanon’s writings criticizing the practices of the School of Algiers. Convinced of the existence of the inferiority of indigenous populations, colonial psychiatrists invented a classification of psychological pathologies based on a supposed psychology of the people. This entire colonial imaginary remains at play in consular attitudes. An imaginary that draws from old colonial assertions, such as Antoine Porot’s definition of North African Indigenous people in the following terms:

“Due to a lack of intellectual curiosity, credulity and suggestibility reach a very high degree. […] The same fatalism exacerbates the indigenous people’s lack of appetite for work, their aboulia, their whims, their impulsivity,” highlighting once again “the lack of care and logic in professional activities, the tendency to lie, to be insolent.” A. Porot adds: “Their psychic life is dominated by instincts and makes little use of the most developed mental faculties.” He also asserts that the “Muslim Maghrebi” possesses a particular subjectivity: “boastful, lying, lazy, feeble, hysterical, criminal, etc.”

So many characteristics lead to the scholarly conclusion that “these primitives cannot and should not benefit from the progress of European civilization,” as affirmed by Alice Cherki, Frantz Fanon’s assistant at the hospital in Tunis, in an interview conducted at her home in Paris on October 21, 2019. This thesis, which is linked to the colonial order of the 1920s, continues to exist underground through the bio-political mechanisms of borders, such as consulates, TLS Contact, Campus France, reception centers, migrant accommodation facilities, identification and expulsion centers, and so on. As a result of this logic, individuals whose visa applications are refused are excluded from access to Western civilization.

The process begins in the case of Tunisian migration to Europe at the time of the visa application. The person hoping to emigrate adopts implement strategies to adapt to the host society, represented by the consulate. The refusal of visa applications renders the process of acculturation pathological and generates frustration, often leading to pathological situations or severe states of stress, including self-aggression. According to Berry and Sam, “the individual’s choice of positioning regarding their culture of origin and that of the host society will define the acculturation strategy, which remains flexible throughout the process. It seems necessary to specify that this choice will be conditioned by the behavior of the host society toward the individual.” The immobility of a migration or travel candidate resembles the immobility of the colonized subject as described by Franz Fanon in The Wretched of the Earth:

“The first thing the native learns is to stay in his place, to not go beyond the limits. This is why the native’s dreams are muscular dreams, dreams of action, aggressive dreams. I dream that I am jumping, swimming, running, climbing. I dream that I am bursting with laughter, that I am crossing the river in a single leap, that I am being pursued by caravans of cars that never catch up with me. During colonization, the colonized never stops releasing himself between nine o’clock in the evening and six o’clock in the morning.”

In this sense, the act of harga (illegal migration by sea) becomes the “dream space” described by Fanon. This act settles in the mind as a sublimatory “line of flight” and adapts to the political context marked by a sudden closure of borders, both external and internal. By prolonging, in different forms, the domination of colonialism, these mechanisms take the place of the ultimate enemy against which young rebels resist.

After being refused a visa by the consulate, a man pondered all sorts of “metaphysical” questions: Who am I? Why was I rejected? Why me? Confronted with a rejection of their desire to travel, facing an arbitrary act that thwarts their desire, it is not uncommon for certain individuals to experience “existential inquiries,” which can lead to a heightened desire for uprooting. They often use the word “hâjja,”[10] which denotes a “furious desire to leave without intending to return!” Their original desire, originating from the Id, has been transformed by their Ego, reshaped, hybridized by the border visa mechanism. Like running away or pathological traveling, “hâjja” is both an almost delirious escape from immense distress and an attempt to reaffirm belonging to humanity, whose freedom has always been expressed through walking, traveling, and seeking unknown horizons.[11]

The Impact of Visa Refusals

Being humiliated by repressive border mechanisms has a major impact on the destinies and desires of those people affected. Another significant effect is the perpetual idealization of a space marked by the massive production of a hierarchized otherness. My interviews with harraga reveal that they continue to be attached to their ideas and representations of Europe, even though their experiences have resulted in visa rejections, imprisonment, marginalization, and deportation. An obsessive idea of leaving the homeland emerges from this moment of visa refusal, causing a psychic wound of being prohibited from traveling (being undesirable). According to Assoun: “The inhibited person leads a restrained life, centered around an obscurely denied enjoyment. They live a life with reduced potential, which does not go as far as the formation of a symptom (Lacan aptly states that it is ‘a symptom put in a museum’). But they live in a permanent discomfort, consisting of never fully completing an action, which creates an embarrassed subject. The inhibited person is always at the starting line, as if halted on the starting block, immobilized at the beginning of their action.”[12]

An effect of mobility withdrawal, a sense of longing for elsewhere and otherness, emerges among inhibited young Tunisians, prematurely obstructing their processes of cultural creation and their experiences of alterity within the emigrant society. This emotional shock can constitute a genuine existential fracture, a wound that can be termed “the trauma of immobility” or “visa refusal trauma.” Moving to another territory then becomes a means of psychological repair and recognition, a way to overcome this self-hatred and the local situation.  Administrative borders are a political mechanism that creates psychological borders and leaves subjects from former colonies stuck and entirely dependent on the metropolises that prohibit them from crossing the borders legally. The prohibition then becomes desired, and racial exploitation and hierarchy are enforced through border mechanisms.

Walls and borders, or what are called “teichopolitics,” have become the main tool for controlling populations in modern domination. The example of the Israeli colonization of Palestine is a striking illustration of this. The destruction of the Gaza wall on October 7, 2023, and the failure of border repression measures forced the State of Israel to revert to a form of conventional warfare to regain control of the colonized territories—the only alternative to wall policies. Subaltern peoples are trapped between two choices: living confined between walls and the sea, or facing total war with all its atrocities if they revolt against these border systems.

[1] The Algiers School of Psychiatry, founded in the 1920s by Antoine Porot, was a colonial psychiatric movement that pathologized North African populations by portraying them as mentally inferior. This school, focused on the “indigenous mentality” and the theory of primitivism, trained a generation of psychiatrists with racist and reductive approaches.

[2] Alexis Spire, Étrangers à la carte, L’administration de immigration en France (1945-1975), Paris, Grasset, 2005, p. 211.

[3] Abdelmalek Sayad, « Naturels et naturalisés », Actes de la recherche en sciences sociales, n° 99, sept. 1993, p205.

[4] Federica Infantino, « La frontière au guichet », Champ pénal/Penal field [En ligne], Vol. VII | 2010, mis en ligne le 12 février 2019, consulté le 06 septembre 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/champpenal/7864 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/champpenal.7864

[5] Established in 2008, Tls Contact (which acts as an intermediary for visa applications) is a major partner company of the Schengen countries. Specializing in services for diplomatic representations, this company is a subsidiary of the telecommunications company Teleperformance Group, a multinational with French capital. The emergence of a “national champion,” a company with a national identity but aspiring to play a global role, dates back to 2007. At that time, as the sector of services for diplomatic representations was experiencing rapid growth, French Senator Gouteyron, affiliated with the UMP party, embraced the existing momentum and encouraged it.

[6] Indeed, the fees for a short-stay Schengen visa (up to 60 days) amount to 80 euros (approximately 240 Tunisian dinars). In addition to the application fees, there is a service fee charged by the company “TLS Contact,” which amounts to 27.50 euros (approximately 62 dinars). None of these fees are refundable in case the visa is not granted. This situation similarly affects Algerian and Moroccan populations. According to official reports, the visa rejection rate for Tunisian citizens was 25% of applications in 2019, doubling the rate from 2018, which was 11.5%. In the first nine months of 2019, the refusal rate was 21.12%, with nearly 137,000 applications and nearly 105,000 visas issued.

[7] Let’s illustrate this point with considerations based on informal observations: According to French Immigration law, a Tunisian undocumented immigrant could obtain legal papers ten years after their initial entry into French territory. The problem is that the law is applied randomly and it is unclear in a similar way to the visa allocation policies implemented by consulates outside the national borders. I have met several harraga individuals who have engaged lawyers to initiate a residence permit procedure upon their arrival in France. The lawyer fees exceed 1,000 euros per year. One person in this situation told me, “I work day and night. Everything I earn goes to the lawyer. I dream of going back to my country and smelling the scent of family and home. I’m exhausted. Do you think I will get my papers?” This person, living in an irregular situation and aged 40, had been waiting for their papers for nine years. They changed lawyers three times without being able to clearly express their suffering or identify possible solutions. The individual I met belongs to these undocumented populations reduced to working to combat their irregular status, exhausted and overshadowed by silence. In other cases I’ve encountered, families in the host country sending money to their sons to help them with the process of obtaining residency papers.

[8] Paul Laurent Assoun. La jouissance entravée. Psychanalyse du sujet empêché, EC, 2013

[9] Didier Bigo, « Le visa Schengen et le recours à la biométrie », in Xavier Crettiez (dir.), Du papier à la biométrie : identifier les individus, Paris, Presses de Sciences Po, 2006, p. 237-267

[10] “Hajja” literally means to leave without returning. It’s a common word in Tunisian slang. When someone is annoyed, they might say, “taw nhej mn ihalibled” (I wish to leave this country). “Hajja” comes from the verb “hâaj,” which describes a person becoming angry or fleeing from injustice to a distant place. You can also find it in expressions like “hâjja aljidara,” which means “he demolished the wall,” or “Hâajat Annarou,” which means “the fire is lit, and its sound has been heard.”

[11] Antonietta Haddad et Gérard Haddad, Freud en Italie… op.cit., p. 28.

[12] Paul Laurent Assoun. La jouissance entravée. Psychanalyse du sujet empêché, EC, 2013